Ava and Wes take the stage after the concert to perform their version of the "ABCs"... hopefully they are safe, and this is not a copyrighted song!
Tonight we attended Taylor and Liv's annual coral concert. Parents everywhere, since video recorders have been inexpensive enough to own, have been recording their children's concerts. I'm sure they were played over and over at every family gathering there in for years... then dug out of the deep dark corners of the basement decades later to humiliate adults everywhere... but we live in different times. Obviously.
With our family literally scattered from one coast to another, I love the idea that I can post a video here on my blog and share these moments, right now (while its still cute and not so much humiliating) with the people who can't be here to attend a 30 min concert in our child's hot cramped gym. Might even be preferable if you ask me. But, last night, we were told in print, and verbally reminded, that we are not allowed to share on "Any social media" the videos we were taking of the concert. This rule, they argued, was due to concerns about the "safety of the children" and the fact that the music is "copyrighted".
I'll tackle the copyright first. As an avid blogger, I post a lot of videos. I use YouTube to host these videos, and YouTube is very rigorous about hosting copyrighted material... If you have followed this blog for awhile, you know that I have posted dozens of videos of my children singing and dancing to popular - ehem, copyrighted- songs. Most of which were playing on some sort of copyrighted device, Pandora, Wii, Movies... you name it. Still, YouTube's copyright filters caught them, checked them out, and eventually (usually only minutes later) published them. Why? Because children dancing and singing to the music, and publishing it on YouTube, only promotes the song. Its a free statement of "look this song is so awesome even these adorable kids love to sing and dance to it!" And lets be real, what artist is going to be threatened by a bunch of 1st and 2nd graders butchering their music? Its not at all like our kids are huge music prodigies putting on a really amazing production. These kids are fidgeting, twisting their shirts and dresses in nervous discourse, belting out the lines, croaking and mumbling their way through the dreaded annual concert that they in no way asked to be a part of. So, with that, I completely reject this copyright material argument for why I cannot share my completely amateur video of my child and their classmates 2nd grade coral performance on my blog, or Facebook, or whatever outlet I choose...
On to the safety excuse. Social media is such a part of life right now. Most of the children I know, are already in someway a part of social media. Even the least technically savvy people that I know, have a Facebook account, and most of them have a photo or two somewhere associated with their account. As for my children, I have posted their photos since they were tiny little babies in the NICU. I do this not to subject them to creepy predators who might be scouring the internet, but because, as I have already said, we have family and friends all over this country (well world... shout out to my international readers! Bonjour la famile de Yollande, Bienvenue!)
Anyway, my point here is that social media, like it or not, is a part of life now. It is as ingrained in our culture as the telephone in our parents generation. Sure, posting these pictures and videos makes it available for people to download and use in what could be unethical means. I don't condone that, but I accept that even with all the privacy settings I have chosen to protect my content, that this may still happen.
I don't see how it is any different than the newspaper posting a picture of kids playing at a public pool, or a sporting event, or a coral concert. The photos/videos are not naming kids specifically, they are not sexually explicit, they are not advertising a school... and because of the file size, they are usually just snip its of video... Again, how is this different from the local news crew filming in front of any event?
I tried to gain some insight here, and searched for news events about elementary school concerts and social media. All the hits were about Billy Joel showing up for an elementary school concert. Nothing about safety concerns related to parent videos and social media.
I love that our schools are beginning to teach our students proper social media etiquette. I think more teachers need to embrace this and include it in their lesson plans. I think the school got this one wrong, its not that we, as parents, should hide our proud home videos from the scaly throngs of social media... no... we should embrace it. I refuse to live in fear that "something bad might happen". Every morning I get up and get into my vehicle knowing that something bad "might" happen, but I still do it and so do you. Therefore, I reject the notion that posting a video or photo of my child and their classmates during their school coral concert is inherently dangerous.